Floating Point Available from Abstract Logix
Music, Video and Concert Reviews
Modern Guitars Magazine Column by Brian D. Holland
Review list of RSS feeds About Brian D. Holland
On An Island by David Gilmour  (March 23, 2006)

On An Island is the first solo release from the Pink Floyd guitarist and vocalist in twenty-two years. The long awaited CD is once again proof of his authoritative talent and a reminder of just how much it was the basis of the band's success. Sure, poor Syd Barrett was no doubt responsible for much of the early psychedelic prose and melody that laid the path to the band's future, a flourishing image that would carry them throughout. However, as time went on, it was Gilmour's hauntingly bluesy and weepy guitar solos that stood out alongside the vocal abilities of both Gilmour and Waters.

Some listeners are often disappointed with the releases of aging rockers, because even though the artist's tastes and aspirations modify over decades, fans have a tendency to see them as they were in their prime. On An Island is a pleasant surprise. Gilmour is blatantly aware of what his fans want from him. Obviously, it's what he desires of himself as well, as he has nothing to prove to anyone.

Much of On An Island, lyrically, is David reminiscing past experiences on a remote island where he once vacationed with friends. That alone lays the groundwork for the melancholy and weepy guitar solos that transpire. The opener, 'Castellorizon', is a hodgepodge of dreamlike effects, the typical Floyd-ish teasing, including the memorable Echos ping alongside a ghostly keyboard string arrangement. That first long awaited guitar solo leads into the rhythmic melody of 'On An Island', a brilliant Gilmour arrangement, both vocally and instrumentally.

'The Blue' delivers a drifty, lethargic atmosphere, ocean-like in this situation, though we've heard Gilmour compositions like this before. 'Breathe' comes to mind. 'Red Sky At Night' gets into a familiar, spacey Richard Wright keyboard arrangement. The Floyd keyboardist is listed as one of the many contributors on the CD. 'Then I Close My Eyes' is a pleasant instrumental, and is a bit reminiscent of Fleetwood Mac's 'Albatross'.

I won't get into all the names, as the contributor list is abundant. However, a few that warrant mentioning are David Crosby and Graham Nash on vocals, Jools Holland on piano, Phil Manzanera on keyboards, and Richard Wright on Hammond organ and vocals.

Gilmour proves throughout that whether it's a Stratocaster or a Gretsch, tone is no doubt in the fingers. This is a dreamy, pleasantly melancholy and mellow, yet significant release. The compositions are awash with charming melodies, the guitar solos are plentiful, and the Floyd ethereal flow is omnipresent. I listen to this CD often and I enjoy it thoroughly. I think it surpasses what one might expect of Gilmour these days. It's better than what I had hoped for. In fact, it's almost Pink Floyd.

On An Island Track Listing
1. Castellorizon
2. On An Island
3. The Blue
4. Take A Breath
5. Red Sky At Night
6. This Heaven
7. Then I Close My Eyes
8. Smile
9. A Pocketful Of Stones
10. Where We Start

Pink Floyd Music Publishers Inc. (BMI) 2006
Produced by David Gilmour, Phil Manzanera, and Chris Thomas

Related Links
David Gilmour
On An Island on Amazon.com


Email a link to this article to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):


To submit for review

Recent Reviews


Monthly Archives


Shop for Music Gear »


Inside Modern Guitars
Welcome to Modern Guitars, where you'll find thousands of guitar related articles covering every style and genre. This page is your gateway to everything from reviews and the latest industry news to an extensive archive of feature stories and exclusive interviews with six-string icons such as Stevie Ray Vaughan, Carlos Santana, Jeff Beck, Bucky Pizzarelli, Les Paul, Zakk Wylde, Lily Afshar, Mike Stern, and a variety of guitar industry leaders including Paul Reed Smith, Christian F. Martin, IV, Bob Taylor, and Henry Juszkiewicz.

MG Magazine Columns
On Axis by Nick Sterling
PSYKO Guitar by Ronny North
Vintage by Saiichi Sugiyama
Guitarology by Tom Hess
Jazz Scope by Steve Herberman
Industry Views by Peter Wolf
Women Rock! by Tish Ciravolo
Jazz Reviews by Vince Lewis
Reviews by Brian D. Holland
Berklee X by Matt Baamonde
Sunset & Vine by Billy Morrison
Hash by John Foxworthy
Functional Art by John Page
Guitar Art by Pamelina H
CRASH Pad by CRASH
Live Art by Neal Barbosa

Site contents copyright Modern Guitars Magazine unless otherwise noted. Contact: news@modernguitars.com